IMBHB MDC Set 1 and 2 for Early Advanced detectors: Tests With CWB 2G

---

This wiki page reports in various tables all the results obtained so far with the cWB on the IMBHB MDC sets 1 and 2. Tables 1-4 refer to the 3-fold network configuration, i.e. HLV. Table 5 to the LIGO-only 2-fold network configuration, i.e. HL. Table 1 reports the preliminary results on the gaussian data set; table 2 reports the first results on the recolored data set (in the following referred to as "old"); table 3 reports the various attempts to optimize the production parameters; finally, table 4 lists the final (up to now) results (in the following referred to as "new"). The main difference between the "new" and the "old" results is that higher post-production thresholds have been applied to greatly reduce the background at the cost of a few percent loss on the range (Mpc). Among the production parameters, the main difference is that we used single-resolution-analysis (RSA) instead of multi-resolution-analisis (MRA): the latter can greatly improve the range for long signals, but it also increases a lot the background. For IMBHB, MRA is not necessary as the SRA is good enough. Moreover, the results on table 4 (4-6) have the injections starting at 10 Hz with taper and minimal search frequency at 16 Hz: the previous results are moderately affected by some artifacts due to the abrupt start of the injections at 25 Hz without tapering. For cWB this is a second-order effect which mostly helps the burst detection as the snr of the artifacts contributes somewhat to the candidates snr. Tables 5 and 6 report the results for the HL network before and after the change on polarization constrains: live time is inclusive of the 3-fold live time. The post-production thresholds have not been carefully tuned yet.

One week of gaussian data: H1L1V1 + EOBNRv2

Beware: injections were done with original xml with waveforms starting abruptly at 25 Hz => small artifacts in the injections, especially the 150-150 Msun.

TABLE 1	LABEL	ANALYSIS TYPE	WAT/LAL vers	Notes	Links
1	EarlyADE _gauss_5-50	2G MRA i, Resamp=3 L=4-10	3447M / 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 1 week, simulation,original xml	factor=1
2	EarlyADE _gauss_50-50	2G MRA i, Resamp=3 L=4-10	3447M / 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 1 week, simulation,original xml, 12 multiplying factors	factor=1
3	EarlyADE _gauss_150-150	2G MRA i, Resamp=3 L=4-10	3447M / 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 1 week, simulation,original xml, 12 multiplying factors	factor=1 factor=2/3
4	EarlyADE _gauss_150-150_25Hz	2G MRA i, Resamp=3 L=4-10	3447M / 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 1 week, simulation,test custom parameters wrt entry #3	factor=1
5	EarlyADE _gauss_150-150_10Hz	2G MRA i, Resamp=3 L=4-10	3447M / 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 1 week, simulation,custom parameters, taper start	factor=1
6	EarlyADE _gauss_bkg_iMRA	2G MRA i, Resamp=3 L=4-10	3447M / 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 1 week, background, 2009 lags (201 lags x 10 slag)	link

2 Months of recolored data: H1L1V1 + EOBNRv2

Beware: injections were done with original xml with waveforms starting abruptly at 25 Hz => small artifacts in the injections, especially the 150-150 Msun.

TABLE 2	LABEL	ANALYSIS TYPE	WAT/LAL vers	Notes	Links
1	EarlyADE _recol_5-50	2G MRA i, Resamp=3 L=4-10	3483M / 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation,original xml 5-50	factor=1
2	EarlyADE _recol_50-50	2G MRA i, Resamp=3 L=4-10	3483M / 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation,original xml 50-50	factor=1
3	EarlyADE _recol_150-150	2G MRA i, Resamp=3 L=4-10	3483M / 6.7.2.1 3483M / 6.12.0.1	2 months, simulation,original xml 150-150	Cit factor=1 Atlas factor=1
4	EarlyADE _recol_bkg	2G MRA i, Resamp=3 L=4-10	3483M / 6.7.2.1	CIT, 2 months, 1004 lags (201 lags x 5 slag)	bkg link

---

New regulator

2 Months of recolored data: H1L1V1 (delta=0.7, gamma=0.2-0.4) + EOBNRv2

Beware: injections were done with original xml with waveforms starting abruptly at 25 Hz => small artifacts in the injections, especially the 150-150 Msun.

TABLE 3	LABEL	ANALYSIS TYPE	WAT/LAL vers	Notes	Links
1	EarlyADE _recol_LHV_5-50_newreg	2G MRA i, Resamp=3 L=4-10	3534M / 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation,original xml 5-50	gamma=0.2 gamma=0.3
2	EarlyADE _recol_LHV_50-50_newreg	2G MRA i, Resamp=3 L=4-10	3534M / 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation,original xml 50-50	gamma=0.2 gamma=0.3
3	EarlyADE _recol_LHV_150-150_newreg	2G MRA i, Resamp=3 L=4-10	3534M / 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation,original xml 150-150	gamma=0.2 gamma=0.3
4	EarlyADE _recol_LHV_bkg	2G MRA i, Resamp=3 L=4-10	3534M/ 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 2 months, 1004 lags (201 lags x 5 slag)	gamma=0.2 gamma=0.3
5	EarlyADE _recol_LHV_bkg2	2G MRA i, Resamp=3 L=4-10	3537M/ 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 2 months, 9045 lags (201 lags x 45 slag)	gamma=0.2
6	EarlyADE _recol_LHV_bkg3	2G, Resamp=3 L=4-10	3549M/ 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 2 months, 9045 lags (201 lags x 45 slag)	iMRA+gamma=0.3
7	EarlyADE_recol_LHV_150-150_newreg3	2G, Resamp=3 L=4-10	3549M/ 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation,original xml 150-150	iMRA + gamma=0.3 iMRA + gamma=0.4 RSRA + gamma=0.3 RSRA + gamma=0.4
8	EarlyADE_recol_LHV_50-50_newreg3	2G, Resamp=3 L=4-10	3549M/ 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation,original xml 50-50	RSRA + gamma=0.3 RSRA + gamma=0.4
9	EarlyADE_recol_LHV_5-50_newreg3	2G, Resamp=3 L=4-10	3549M/ 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation,original xml 5-50	RSRA + gamma=0.3 iMRA + gamma=0.3

---

After tuning of post-production cuts (and with injections starting at 10 Hz, i.e. no injection artifacts)

2 Months of recolored data: H1L1V1 (RSRA delta=0.7, gamma=0.4)

Injected Waveforms: EOBNRv2, SEOBNRv2, IMRPhenomP, IMRPhenomC

Thresholds : netcc[0]>0.7 && netcc[1]>0.7 && netcc[2]>0.6 && neted[0]/ecor<0.4 &&penalty>0.9

Analysis type : 2G RSRA, Resamp=3 L=4-10, fmin=16Hz

TABLE 4	LABEL	WAT/LAL vers	Notes	Effective Radius [Mpc]	Links
1	EarlyADE_recol_LHV_5-50_newreg3_10Hz	3655M/ 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation, EOBNR 5-50 @10Hz taper start	109	report page
2	EarlyADE_recol_LHV_5-50_*MDC2_SEOBNR	3986M/ 6.13.3.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation, SEOBNR 5-50 @10Hz taper start	116	report page
3	EarlyADE_recol_LHV_5-50_myMDC2_IMRPhenomP2	4105:4111M/ 6.13.4.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation, IMRPhenomP 5-50 @10Hz (custom xml) taper start	135	report page
4	EarlyADE_recol_LHV_50-50_newreg3_10Hz	3583M/ 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation, EOBNR 50-50 @10Hz taper start	600	report page
5	EarlyADE_recol_LHV_50-50_*MDC2_SEOBNR	3986M/ 6.13.3.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation, SEOBNR 50-50@10Hz taper start original xml custom xml with increased statistics (12 non-overlapping concentric shells) 3. custom xml with increased statistics (12 non-overlapping concentric shells)+fiducial volume increased up to 2 Gpc	572 571 591	report page original xml report page increased stat report page increased fiducial volume
6	EarlyADE_recol_LHV_50-50_myMDC2_IMRPhenomC	4008:4016M / 6.13.4.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation, IMRPhenomC 50-50 @10Hz (custom xml) taper start	579	report page
7	EarlyADE_recol_LHV_50-50_myMDC2_IMRPhenomP2	4105:4111M/ 6.13.4.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation, IMRPhenomP 50-50 @10Hz (custom xml) taper start	578	report page
8	EarlyADE_recol_LHV_150-150_newreg3_10Hz	*3583M/ 6.12.0.1*	Atlas, 2 months, simulation, EOBNR 150-150 @10Hz taper start	643	report page
9	EarlyADE_recol_LHV_150-150_*MDC2_SEOBNR	3986M/ 6.13.3.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation, SEOBNR 150-150 @5 Hz (custom xml) taper start	633	report page
10	EarlyADE_recol_LHV_150-150_myMDC2_IMRPhenomP2	4105:4111M/ 6.13.4.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation, IMRPhenomP 150-150 @5Hz (custom xml) taper start	622	report page
11	EarlyADE _recol_LHV_bkgall	*3583M/ 6.12.0.1*	Atlas, 2 months, 10049 lags (201 lags x 50 slag)	-	report page
12	EarlyADE _recol_LHV_bkgall_16Hz	3583M/ 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 2 months, 10049 lags (201 lags x 50 slag)	-	report page
13	EarlyADE _recol_LHV_bkgall_16Hz_cat3	3655M/ 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 2 months, 65049 lags	-	report page
14		*3583M/ 6.12.0.1*	*ZERO LAG: no events above chosen thresholds, so I lowered the netcc[0] and rho to have a few events showing up*	-	report page

---

HLV Reconstruction statistics

---

2 Months of recolored data: H1L1 (RSRA delta=2.0, gamma=2.0)

Injected Waveforms: EOBNRv2 and SEOBNRv2

Thresholds : netcc[0]>0.6 && netcc[1]>0.7 && netcc[2]>0.6 && neted[0]/ecor<0.4 &&penalty>0.9

Analysis type : 2G RSRA, Resamp=3 L=4-10, fmin=16Hz

TABLE 5	LABEL	WAT/LAL vers	Notes	Effective Radius [Mpc]	Links
1	EarlyADE_recol_LH_5-50_newreg3_10Hz	3655 M/ 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation, EOBNR 5-50 @10Hz taper start		report page
2	EarlyADE_recol_LH_5-50_*MDC2_SEOBNR	3986M/ 6.13.3.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation, SEOBNR 5-50 @10Hz taper start		report page
3	EarlyADE_recol_LH_50-50_newreg3_10Hz	3655M/ 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation, EOBNR 50-50 @10Hz taper start		report page
4	EarlyADE_recol_LH_50-50_*MDC2_SEOBNR	3986M/ 6.13.3.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation, SEOBNR 50-50 @10Hz taper start		report page
5	EarlyADE_recol_LH_150-150_newreg3_10Hz	3655M/ 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation, EOBNR 150-150 @10Hz taper start		report page
6	EarlyADE_recol_LH_150-150_*MDC2_SEOBNR	3986M/ 6.13.3.1	Atlas, 2 months, simulation, SEOBNR 150-150 taper start		report page original xml report page custom xml @ 5Hz
7	EarlyADE _recol_LH_bkg_16Hz	3655M/ 6.12.0.1	Atlas, 2 months, 110549 lags (201 lags x 550 slag)		report page
8	EarlyADE _recol_LH_bkg_16Hz	3655M/ 6.12.0.1	ZERO LAG		report page

HL Reconstruction statistics

---

---

2 Months of recolored data: H1L1 new polarization constrains ( WAT Version >= 6.0.2)

Injected Waveforms: EOBNRv2, SEOBNRv2, IMRPhenomP

Thresholds : netcc[0]>0.6 && netcc[1]>0.7 && netcc[2]>0.6

Analysis type : 2G RSRA/iMRA, delta=0.5, gamma=0.75 , Resamp=3 L=4-10, fmin=16Hz

TABLE 6	LABEL	WAT/LAL vers	Notes	Effective Radius (@rho[0]=7) [Mpc]	Links
1	EarlyADE_LH_5-50_MDC1_EOBNR	4345M/ 6.13.4.1	Atlas, simulation, EOBNR 5-50 @10Hz taper start	128	RSRA
				128	iMRA
2	EarlyADE_LH_50-50_MDC1_EOBNR	4345M/ 6.13.4.1	Atlas, simulation, EOBNR 50-50 @10Hz taper start	665	RSRA
				655	iMRA
3	EarlyADE_LH_150-150_MDC1_EOBNR	4345M/ 6.13.4.1	Atlas, simulation, EOBNR 150-150 @10Hz taper start	709	RSRA
				686	iMRA
4	EarlyADE_LH_5-50_MDC2_SEOBNR	4274M/ 6.13.4.1	Atlas, simulation, SEOBNR 5-50 @10Hz taper start	131	RSRA
				133	iMRA
5	EarlyADE_LH_50-50_MDC2_SEOBNR	4274M/ 6.13.4.1	Atlas, simulation, SEOBNR 50-50 @10Hz taper start	648	RSRA
				644	iMRA
6	EarlyADE_LH_150-150_MDC2_SEOBNR	4274M/ 6.13.4.1	Atlas, simulation, SEOBNR 150-150 @10Hz taper start	693	RSRA
				676	iMRA
7	EarlyADE_LH_5-50_myMDC2_IMRPhenomP	4345M/ 6.13.4.1	Atlas, simulation, IMRPhenomP 5-50 @10Hz taper start	149	RSRA
				149	iMRA
8	EarlyADE _LH_50-50_myMDC2_IMRPhenomP	4345M/ 6.13.4.1	Atlas, simulation, IMRPhenomP 50-50 @10Hz taper start	656	RSRA
				646	iMRA
9	EarlyADE _LH_150-150_myMDC2_IMRPhenomP	4345M/ 6.13.4.1	Atlas, simulation, IMRPhenomP 150-150 @5Hz taper start	698	RSRA
				673	iMRA
10	EarlyADE_LH_bkgall_16Hz	4274M/ 6.13.4.1	Atlas, BKG 150749 lags (201 lags x 550 slag)		RSRA
					iMRA
11	EarlyADE_LH_bkg_16Hz	4274M/ 6.13.4.1	ZERO LAG		RSRA
					iMRA

-- FrancescoSalemi - 12 Jun 2014